Approaching the conclusion of the 2023 college football season, the competition for a spot in the College Football Playoff has intensified. In the latest rankings released by the College Football Playoff Selection Committee, the noteworthy shift occurred near the top, with Washington surging past Florida State to claim the No. 4 spot.
Despite the Seminoles effortlessly handling North Alabama, their triumph was overshadowed by the loss of starting quarterback and Heisman Trophy contender, Jordan Travis, who sustained a season-ending leg injury in the first quarter. Meanwhile, the Huskies were making waves by securing a victory over No. 16 Oregon State on the road in Corvallis. This win marked Washington’s third conquest over a current top 25 team, adding to their home victory against No. 6 Oregon and a road win over No. 15 Arizona.
A critical examination of the teams’ resumes reveals Washington’s superiority, boasting wins over a more substantial number of ranked opponents compared to Florida State. The Seminoles’ credentials include only two victories against ranked teams — a neutral site win over No. 14 LSU to kick off the season and an overtime win at No. 24 Clemson. The decision to elevate Washington over Florida State is not only justifiable but arguably fitting. Approaching the conclusion
Although FSU fans may express frustration, the narrative is far from complete, especially for the Seminoles. The true character of the team with Tate Rodemaker at the helm remains uncertain. Rodemaker could potentially emulate the success of Cardale Jones, who led Ohio State to a title in 2014 as a third-string quarterback. Until more information surfaces, keeping Florida State ahead of a Washington team with an unblemished albeit occasionally unconvincing record seems unwarranted.
The committee, while acknowledging the influence of injuries, leaves the process of consideration somewhat ambiguous. Rodemaker’s performance on the field could significantly sway committee impressions. Whether he shines in the spotlight or the Seminoles narrowly escape, the committee’s evaluation of Florida State’s current form will likely play a decisive role in determining their College Football Playoff eligibility.
In the end, it might matter. If Florida State wins out and tops No. 10 Louisville in the ACC Championship Game, that would be a beautiful stroke of the paintbrush to close out the picture, especially under the direction of backup quarterback. For now, though, it’s perfectly fine for Washington to be No. 4 while we wait for the paint to dry.